$B%a%k%^%,!'(Btoxandoria$B$NF|5-(B
$B%?%$%H%k!'?7%3%m%J$N7Y9p!?%U%!%7%:%`(B2.0$B!V?7<+M3

$B"#?7%3%m%J$N7Y9p!?%U%!%7%:%`(B2.0$B!V?7<+M3o!Y!J#1!?#2!K!](B3

$B!cCm!d$*
2  $B%D%Y%?%s!&%H%I%m%U!XL1  $B!J<+M386M}  
$B!XL1G7!&Lu!]$_$9$:=qK2H!K$K$h$l$P!"%-%j%9%H65!J0l?@65!K$G$O!"$=$N?@$,AOB$$9$k$h$jA0$N@$3&$O9M$($J$$!#$+$D!"$=$N?@$O<+$i$K;w$;$F%R%H$rAO$C$?$H$5$l$k!#(B

$B8N$K!"?@$H$[$\F1Ey$N!J$I$3$^$G;w$;$F$b5v$5$l$k$N$+!)$=$NDxEY!J?@$XI~=>$9$Y$-HO0O!K$K4X$o$kO@Ah$,!"%"%&%0%9%F%#%L%9(BVs$B%Z%i%.%&%9!"$NBPN)!&93Ah!u0[C2$$N@$3&4Q$N2<$G2f$o$l?MN`$K$O!c?JJb$H?ML1!J8D?M$N8"Mx!K!d$NL$Mh$r@Z$j3+$-!"D>@~E*$KL$Mh$X8~$+$C$F!">/$7$G$b$h$jNI$$K-$+$J@$3&$rAO$jB3$1$k!c<+M3!?!H86:a$K$D$$$F$NM}2r!I$H4X$o$k!d!JFC$K%W%m%F%9%?%s%H$K$*$$$F$O5AL3!)!K$,$"$k$H$$$&$3$H$K$J$k!#(B

$B!cCm!d86:a$H<+M3$NM}2r$K$D$$$F!&!&!&=t@b$"$k$,!"0l1~$O!V%"%@%`$H%$%t$,<+M3$N86M}$K4X$o$k?@$N<(:6$NL5;k!W$H$$$&$3$H$,86:a$N0UL#$G$"$k!"$HM}2r$G$-$k!#$J$*!"ElJ}652q$O86:a$=$N$b$N$rG'$a$F$$$J$$$H$5$l$k!JMW;2>H;qNA!?"-!z!K!#(B
$B!z%Z%i%.%&%9GI$K$h$k86:aO@HcH=$NK\!?Cf@$E/3X2q!!(Bhttp://jsmp.jpn.org/jsmp_wp/wp-content/uploads/smt/vol60/115-123_tokushu-yamada.pdf
 $B!&!&!&!!(B
$B%H%I%m%U$K$h$l$P!"Nr;KE*$K8+$k$H%-%j%9%H65$N@$3&$G$O?@$,5vMF$9$k0lDj$NHO0O$G$N<+M3$rNI$7$H$9$k$N$,@5E}$G$"$j!":GBg8B$K<+N'E*$J?M4V$H$7$F$N<+M3$rB:=E$9$Y$-$H$9$k$N$O0[C<$H$5$l$F$-$?!J0x$_$K(B12$B@$5*%9%3%C%H%i%s%I$G$O%h%O%M%9!&%I%&%s%9!&%9%3%H%&%9!J(BJohannes Duns Scotus$B!?(B1266-1308$B!K$K$h$kN>o$KCfMG$J<+M3O@$,@8$^$l$F$*$j!"$3$l$,7
$B0lJ}!"6aBe!V2J3X3WL?!W$N=l$N;~Be$G$b$"$C$?J)3WL?8e$N(B18$B@$5*Kv!A(B20$B@$5*=iF,$K$+$1$F$N5^B.$J2J3XM}2r$N?<2=$H2J3X5;=Q$N?JJb$H$bAjPX$C$F!"6&;:
$B7+$jJV$9$,%-%j%9%H65$G$O?@$,8=$l$k$h$jA0$N@$3&$K$D$$$F$O9M$($J$$!J%]%9%H?@$N5/E@$+$i;~4V$,0lD>@~$K?J$`!K$3$H$,BgA0Ds$G$"$j!"$3$NE@$3$=!VNX2v$N4QG0$rA0Ds$H$9$kJ)65@$3&!W$H!VD>@~E*$K;~4V$,?d0\$9$k%-%j%9%H65@$3&!W$H$N7hDjE*$J0c$$$r$b$?$i$7$F$$$k!#$^$?!"M$K4X$o$k8&5f!W!JFC$KG>2J3X%U%#!<%k%I!K$G$b!"$3$N$h$&$J0UL#$G$N!VEl@>$K$*$1$k=!654Q$N:,K\E*$J:90[!W$,8&5fH"-!z!K!#(B

$B!z!ZDMED(B $BL-!'=qI>![%&%*!<%?!$O$$$+$K$7$F?4$rAO$k$N$+(B&#8212;$B?@7P2sO)LV$N%+%*%9$,@8$_=P$9;V8~@-!&0UL#!&<+M30U;W(B&#8212;$B!W@uLn9'M:!&Lu!J:k6L0e2JBg3XL>M@65.@n@V==;zIB1!L>M@1!D9!K!&!&!&SL5e(B(olfactory bulb)$B$O!"G>DlIt$N5lS.F}N`G>$N0lIt$,I!9P>eJ}$KFM=P$7$F7A@.$9$k5e>u$N9=B$J*$G$"$k!#I!9P$NSL>eHi$KE~C#$7$?SL$$$NJ,;R$,!"Kv>?  $B!&!&!&(B
$B$=$l8N!"@>2$$N@$3&4Q$N2<$G$O!"D>@~E*$KL$Mh$X8~$+$C$F?J$_$D$D!VK0$/$J$-?JJb$HK-$+$5$X$NM_K>$H?ML1!J8D?M!K$N8"Mx$NNN0h!W$r@Z$j3+$-!">/$7$G$b$h$jNI$$7P:QE*$KK-$+$J@$3&$rAO$jB3$1$k!c<+M3!d!JFC$K%W%m%F%9%?%s%H$K$*$$$F$O$=$l!JK-$+$5$r
$B6aG/!"%^%C%/%9!&%&%'!<%P!  
$B"!1)F~C$O:!X%^%C%/%9!&%t%'!<%P!<$NHH:a!?!XNQM}!YO@J8$K$*$1$k;qNAA`:n$N:>=Q$H!VCNE*@? $B!&!&!&(B
$B$7$+$7!"$$$:$l$K$;$h!"%W%m%F%9%?%s%H$N!V>/$7$G$b$h$jNI$$7P:QE*$KK-$+$J@$3&$rAO$jB3$1$k!c<+M3!d$r5a$a$k6/$$0U;W!W$3$=$,!J$=$l$O!"$[$\J;9T$7$F?J$s$G$-$?7
$B=>$C$F!"JF%H%i%s%W8=>]!J?7<+M3!K$i$N!VGS30%]%T%e%j%:%`!J<+8J!J<+9q!KBh0ll86M}j!JL58B$N%*!<%P!<%U%m!$H2=$7$?!"<+M386M}
$B!J?<9o2=$9$k!H?7<+M3!J<+M386M}!K $B<~CN$N$H$*$j!"l$H2=$7$?$+$K8+$($k!V(B1970$BG/Be0J9_!A8=:_$K;j$kLsH>@$5*$K$*$h$V;~Be!W$O!"$$$^$d;_$^$k$3$H$rCN$i$L$+!*$H$5$(8+$($k7c$7$$!V3J:9!W3HBg$N%H%l%s%I$,@$3&$r?LY~$5$;B3$1$F$-$?$H$$$($k!#$=$7$F!"6aG/$K$J$C$F$+$i!"$=$N?<9o$J7P:Q!V3J:9!W$K$h$k
$BA3$k$K!"%D%t%'%?%s!&%H%I%m%U$O0JA0$+$i$3$NLdBj$r;XE&$7$F$*$j!">e7G=p!XL1
$B$=$l$K$b$+$+$o$i$:!"!V?7%3%m%J%&%$%k%9!W$H!V%&%=EG$-$^$/$k%"%Y$5$^$N%5%/%i%9%-%c%s%@%k!WEy$N7vA{$,!H%U%/%7%^(B3.11$B$K$D$$$F$N9qL1$N4X?4!I$r%9%C%+%jA_$->C$7$F$7$^$C$?$+$N$h$&$J6u5$$N$J$+$G!"!V=w@n86H/#29f5!!?:F2TF0=`Hw!&8!::9g3J!?"-"%!W$N%K%e!<%9$,KX$I%N!/$JF|K\$N=K;v!J$$$o$$$4$H!K$+!"$"$k$$$OL@$k$$=PMh;v$G$b$"$k$+$NG!$/?b$lN.$5$l$?!#(B

 $B"%5\>k(B $B=w@n86H/#29f5!(B $B5,@)0Q0w2q$N?3::$K9g3J(B2020$BG/(B2$B7n(B26$BF|(BNHK$B!!(Bhttps://www3.nhk.or.jp/news/html/20200226/k10012301761000.html?fbclid=IwAR1_a1cBuN5KaqHFpLo8Xfr83hug398dxvxlhRiML2ftPmLA5plRnTD87s8

$B!&!&!&%"%Y!H%U%/%7%^!&%"%s%@!<%3%s%H%m!<%k@k8@$H$$$&0-me$J13!I$O$=$N?<9o2=$NE57?;vNc!&!&!&(B

$B!z#1!!(B[$Bk8)=w@nD.!"@P4,;T!K$K$D$$$F!"86;RNO5,@)0Q0w2q$O?75,@)4p=`$KE,9g$9$k$HG'$a$??3::=q$r@5<07hDj$7$^$7$?!#!&!&!&F186H/$r$a$0$C$F$O!"86H/$=$N$b$N$N4m81@-$K$H$I$^$i$:!"HrFq7W2h$NJN,!&!&!&(B20200228$B@V4z!"(Bhttps://www.jcp.or.jp/akahata/aik19/2020-02-28/2020022801_05_1.html 

$B!z#2!ZO"A[![!H86H/%^%M!<<06L:U!I!)!?%\%m%\%m!*=w@n86H/#29f5!$K$R$S#1#1#3#0%+=j![<+L1E^!&8xL@E^$i$O2?8N$K:F2TF/$r6/9T$7$h$&$H$9$k$N$+!)%+%_%+%<86H/$N$D$b$j$+!)86H/%^%M!<$N$?$a$+!)(B
https://twitter.com/tadanoossan2/status/1186364304842317824

$B!z(B3  $B%U%/%7%^#29f5!!VGzH/!W4m5!$N2sHr$,@.8y$N2J3XE*:,5r$OL$2rL@!*0BG\%"%s%@!<%3%s%H%m!<%k<0!VBg13!W$N:a$O=E$/3f$b$=$l$O?7%3%m%J9T@/8!::$G$NH/>M!V7o?t!WM^@)$N5=bV!uP~K}$K=E$J$k!*(B &#10174;$B=*$o$j$H;O$^$j!'%U%/%7%^!"8=>l$NJ3F.(B $B!V6vA3!W$N@84T!";W$$=P$7$F(B $BCS_72F  
$B!z(B4 $B!VJ!EgBh0l86H/(B3$B9f5!$O3KGzH/$@$C$?!W86H/@_7W5;=Q  
$B!&!&!&(B

$B!J%D%t%'%?%s!&%H%I%m%U$,;XE&$9$k?7<+M3
$B!&!&!&?7<+M3
$B%D%t%'%?%s!&%H%I%m%U$,Cx=q!XL1]E*!&IaJWE*2ACM4Q$N=EMW@-$H$$$&$3$H!"!J#2!KF1$8$/H`$i$,7
$B$^$:!"%H%I%m%U$O!J#1!K$K$D$$$F!V?7<+M3HH!?"-"%!K$,=q$$$?FbMF$r0zMQ$9$k!#A4J8E>:\$G$OD9$/$J$j2a$.$k$N$G!"0J2<$K$=$N!XMWE@!Y$rCj=P$7$FE>:\$9$k!#(B

$B"%%(%I%^%s%I!&%P!<%/!J(BEdmund Burke$B!?(B1729-1797$B!K!'%"%$%k%i%s@8$^$l$N1Q9q$N@/<#(B $B;WA[2H!&E/3X
 $B!X$"$k;v>]$K4X$o$k0l@Z$N=t4X78$r@ZCG$7$F!"7A<)>e3XE*Cj>]$K$h$kMg$G8IN)>uBV$K$"$k;v>]$=$l<+BN$7$+8+$J$$$N$G$"$l$P!";d$O@UG$$r;}$C$F?M4V$N<+M3$K4X$o$k9TF0$dLdBj$K4X78$9$k$3$H$K$D$$$F>N;?$9$Y$-$+!"HsFq$9$Y$-$+$r!"$^$C$?$/6hJL$9$k$3$H$,$G$-$J$$!#$^$?!"Nc$($P8"NO$r;HMQ$9$k<+M3$G$"$C$F$b!"$=$l$OG!2?$K;HMQ$5$l$k$+$GH=CG$5$l$k$Y$-$G$"$C$F!"Cj>]E*$KH=CG$5$l$k$Y$-$G$O$J$$!#2?$b;d$N9TF0$r@)8B$7$J$1$l$P!";d$O@d$($:A}Bg$9$k8"NO$r3MF@$9$k$3$H$K$J$k!#$3$N8"NO$O;d$,K>$b$&$,K>$`$^$$$,!"<~0O$NB>$N8D?M$r5>@7$K$7$F9T;H$5$l$k!#FC$K!"$=$l$,@/<#E*$J$b$N$G$"$k>l9g$O!"H`$i$O$=$&$9$k$3$H$G!"2:7r$G$"$m$&$H$7$F$$$?@/I\$N$?$a$K%b%s%F%9%-%e!<$,I=L@$7$?2+6bN'$rK:$l$k$N$G$"$k!#$9$J$o$A!"L5:]8B$N8"NO$O@5E}$G$O$"$j$($J$$$@$m$&!#!Y(B

$B!cCm!d$3$N%b%s%F%9%-%e!<$,I=L@$7$?2+6bN'$N$J$+$G0LCVIU$1$i$l$k!V<+M3!W$O!"!VBh#2>O!]%b%s%Z%k%i%s6(2q$NM}G0$NJQE*$JCj>]E*IaJW$K<|$o$l$F$$$k$H$$$&M}2r$O8m$j$G$"$k!#(B
 
$B$H$b$+$/$b!"$3$N%H%I%m%U$N!J#1!K!V?7<+M3o$K9bEYCj>]2=$7$?35G0K0OB!W$,!c0l@Z$N?-=L@-$r<:$$8GCe2=$7$?$b$N!d$@$H%;%$%d!<$O
$B$D$^$j!"$3$NE@$3$=$,%H%I%m%U$N!J#1!K!V?7<+M3
$B$H$3$m$G!V35G0K0OB!W$,%;%$%d!<$iHcH=]E*$J8@MU$NDj5A!J35G0!K$J$I$,!"$"$kDxEY$O0lDj$NHO0O$K;_$^$k$3$H$,$J$1$l$P!"2f$o$l$NF|>oE*$J%3%_%e%K%1!<%7%g%s$,
$B=>$C$F!"$=$N$h$&$J0UL#$G0lDj$NHO0O$G8@MU$KH<$&35G0$NHO0O$,N1$^$k$3$H$O!"$=$l<+BN$,35G0K0OB$G$"$j!"$=$N$h$&$J0UL#$G$N35G0K0OB$O!"?M4Vo2qOC$G$N%3%_%e%K%1!<%7%g%s$OL5O@$N$3$H!"FC$KK!N'$d2J3X5;=Q$J$I@lLgJ,Ln$NMQ8l$G$OCWL?E*$JLdBj$K7R$,$k$3$H$K$J$k$@$m$&!#(B

$B0lJ}!"$b$N$4$H$r42MF$KM}2r$7$?$j!"1JB3E*$K?.MQ$r7R$.N1$a$?$j!"B?MM@-$rBg@Z$K$7$?$j!"$"$k$$$O%$%N%t%'!<%7%g%s!&?7H/8+!&7]=QE*AOB$@-$dK-$+$JA[A|NO$NH/4x$J$I$N$?$a$K$O!"$=$N0UL#$G$N35G0K0OB!J$3$l$O35G05,Dj$H8@$&$Y$-$@$,!K$KM>$j$K$b2a>j$K8GCe$9$k$H!"$=$l$i$K4X$9$k?7$7$$2DG=@-$dG=NOH/4x$N5!2q$rF($7$?$j!"Kt$O%R%H$K$H$j:G$b=EMW$J?M4V@-$rGK2u$7$?$j?MF;>e$NHH:a$rHH$7$?$j$9$kG!$-0-9T$5$(!"?M4V
$B$D$^$j!"!V%&%=EG$-!&%I%m%\!o=,HH$*Cg4V$3$H!V0BG\%5%/%i@/8"!?%U%!%7%:%`(B2.0$B!W$,0l6/;YG[$9$k:#$NF|K\$G!"L\2$C$F!"0BG\?8;0;a$r?r$aJt$k=t8"NO%0%k!<%W$N$*Cg4V$i$O!"$H$F$bIaDL$N0UL#$G$N?M4V$H$O8@$$Fq$$B8:_$G$"$k!##w(B

$B=>$C$F!"$3$3$G=EMW$J$N$,!"$=$N8D!9$N!V35G0K0OB!W$r%3%_%e%K%1!<%7%g%s$NG^2p:`NA$H$7$FF|>oE*$KMxMQ$9$kI,MW$,$"$k?M4V$C$F!"?tM}E*$J$=$l$OJL$H$7$FCj>]35G0$=$N$b$N$5$($b!K$,!"$=$l<+BN$H$7$F$O@dBP$KFHN)E*$KD6A3$HB8:_!J7/NW!K$9$k$3$H$O$G$-$:!"I,$:2f$o$l$O!V%(%H%N%9<+A3!&J82=4D6-!W$H?tB?$N!V%R%H$N@8L?$N0l2s@-!W$H$N7k$S$D$-$N6&LD$H43>D$N>l$N$J$+$G@8$+$5$l!"@8$-$F$$$kB8:_$J$N$@$H$$$&!"$=$N$h$&$J0UL#$G8,5u$J!c8=
$B$D$^$j!"8@$$49$($l$P$3$N!V%(%H%N%9<+A3!&J82=4D6-!W$H!V2f$o$l?M4Vr7o!W$H$9$l$P!"$?$H$($3$l$,@lLgMQ8l$N35G05,Dj$N0b$$$G$N!V35G0K0OB!W$G$"$k$H$7$F$b!"Kt$O$?$H$($=$l$,7]E*$J!K$G$"$C$?$H$7$F$b!"$=$N0UL#$r<~0O$d!!]$NK|G=$N?@$J$I$G$O$J$$$+$i$@!#(B

$B$J$*!"Fs$DL\$N!V!J#2!KF1$8$/H`$i$,7JN,$9$k!#(B

$B$$$5$5$+0[$J$k;kE@$+$i8+$k$H!"$3$N%;%$%d!<$Nl86M}]E*$G8GCeE*$J@$3&$KVH$C$?35G0K0OB$NE57?!d$@$H$$$&$3$H$G$"$k!#%;%$%d!<$NCx=q!X46$N?M!W$H$5$l$k$3$H$,B?$$$h$&$@$,!J(Bhttps://jww.iss.u-tokyo.ac.jp/jss/pdf/jss6402_167170.pdf$B!K!"l86M}l7P:Q$,J*
$B$^$?!"%;%$%d!<$K$h$l$P!"%U%j!<%I%^%s$KFCD'E*$J!VCj>]35G04pDlE*$J0UL#!W$G$N!HCj>]!I35G0K0OB$r<($9E57?E*$JI=8=$O%_%k%H%s!&%U%j!<%I%^%s<+?H$,9%$s$G;H$C$?!V@0=xOHAH$_!W!J%U%!%$%j%s%0!&%7%9%F%`!K$H$$$&MQ8l$G$"$k!#$$$o$P!"%U%!%$%j%s%0!&%7%9%F%`$NG!$/!VJ,N`!&O@M}!&BN7O!WE*$K@0A3$HG[Ns$5$lB3$1$k7P:QM}O@BN7O$N%$%a!<%8$G$"$k!#$@$+$i!"$3$3$G$O!V%j%"%k7P:Q$K4X$o$k5R4Q!&]35G0E*$Jl7P:Q$NM}2r$K$D$$$F5wN%$rCV$/$N$,%7%e%s%Z!<%?!<$G$"$k$,!"$3$l$K$D$$$F$N0Q:Y$OBh#4>O$XAw$k!#(B

$B0x$_$K!"%U%j!<%I%^%s$N!V@0=xOHAH$_!W$K$D$$$F$O!"$3$N@b$KBPV5$9$k$+$N$h$&$J0[@b$b$"$k$3$H$r?=$7E:$($F$*$/!#Nc$($P!"2<5-!z$,$"$k!#$?$@!"$3$NE@$K$D$$$F$O!V%U%j!<%I%^%s$N40A4<+M386M}O$G>\=R!K$H$NMm$_$G!"2L$?$7$F%U%j!<%I%^%s$,%W%i%0%^%F%#%:%`!JFC$K%G%e!<%$$N!K$r2?=h$^$G@53N$KM}2r$7$F$$$?$N$+!)$H$$$&0UL#$G5?LdId$,$D$/!#(B

$B!z%_%k%H%s!&%U%j!<%I%^%s$NF;6ql86M}!Il86M}$NAD$H8+$J$5$l$k%_%k%H%s(B.$B%U%j!<%I%^%s$G$O$"$k$,!"!V=EMWO@J8(BF35$B!W$NFI$_D>$7$+$i!"$P$+$j$G$"$C$?!*!w1'Bt90J8!K$G%M%C%H%o!<%/2=$7!"??$N7P:QM}O@$,40@.$9$kKx$N$5$7Ev$j$NF;6q$H$7$F$N;T>l86M}$G$"$k!?F;6ql86M}!W!d$H9M$($F$$$?@a$,$"$k$H!"M}2r$G$-$k!#(Bhttps://www.chuo-u.ac.jp/uploads/2018/11/2988_31122discussno167.pdf?1552953600201

$B$H$b$+$/$b!"FC$K!H0l2s@-!I$H!H1JB3@-86M}!I$N66EO$7$H8+$k$Y$-@8L?!&@8BVO@$*$h$S%j%"%k$J?M4Vo@-$H?<$/4X$o$k?MJ8!&l$G
$B$@$+$i!":G$b9-HO$J;k:B!J5U@b$KJ9$3$($k$+$b$7$l$J$$$,!K$rDs6!$9$kE/3X!&NQM}$3$=$,:G$b=EMW$G$"$j!"$=$NE/3X$rMj$j$K!V@0=xOHAH$_!W!J%_%k%H%s!&%U%j!<%I%^%s$,9%$s$@MQ8l!K$X$N%W%m%;%9$r!"@d$($:9-3Q$N;k:B$+$iBg7O$E$1$7D>$9$3$H$,=EMW$G$O$J$$$+!)L5O@!"$3$l$OFC$K?MJ8!&l$+$i%R%H$rG'CNM}O@E*$KM}2r$9$k$?$a$K$b!"5f6KE*$K$O$=$N$h$&$J;k:B$,I,?\$G$"$m$&!#(B
 
$B$5$b$J$1$l$P!"!V2J3X$N2a>j%5!<%S%92=!J!w%+!<%k!&%^%k%/%9!?%G%t%#%C%I!&%O!<%t%'%$$N2r
$B!cJdB-!d@8L?BN$G$"$k%R%H$N;W9M!J0U<1!K$K$*$1$k35G0K0OB$O2J3X!J2=3X!&J*M}$i!K$N!VK0OB!W$H$O0UL#$,0[$J$k!#$=$l$O!"%R%H$N35G0K0OB$K$OKX$IL58B$N<+:_@-!J?-=L<+:_@-!K$,$"$k$,!"2J3X$N$=$l$K$OL5@)8B$J?-=L<+:_@-$,4pK\E*$K$O$"$jF@$J$$$+$i!#$^$?!"$*$=$i$/!V35G0K0OB!W$N4QG0$O!V%^%C%O463PO@E*AG:`@-!JO@!K!W!J%^%C%O8=>]3X!?(BCf.$B"-(B&#9832;$B!K$N9M$(J}$H2?$i$+$N4X$o$j9g$,$"$k$H9M$($i$l$k!JEv%V%m%05-;v$K4X$o$k8B$j$H$$$&0UL#$G$@$,!"$=$l$OL$$@J88%N`$G$N3NG'$,$G$-$F$$$J$$!*!K!#(B
 
Claude Monet$B!](BYoung Girls in a Boat.$B!!(B1887. Oil on canvas. National Museum of Western Art, Tokyo, Japan./Olga's Gallery
&#9832; $B:F$S!"%^%C%O8=>]3X$H%^%C%O463PO@E*AG:`O@!J@-!K$K$D$$$F$N9M;!$,I,?\!&!&!&!VF1$8$H;W$o$l$k8w7J!W$G$b2f$o$l$O0[$J$k8==P!J]!K$r8+$F$$$k!?$,!"0lJ}$G$=$N:GBg8xLs$NI=>]!J:GBg$N6&DL9`$H$J$k!K$,5R4Q@-!J4VZ$9$k!K$G$"$k!"(Bhttps://toxandoria.hatenablog.com/entry/20180701/p1

 $B!JK0$/$J$-2a>j$NM_K>$X$NHcH=NO$?$k%3%s%7%j%(%s%9$HHcH=l!K(B

 $B!VHcH=H(B&#10174;$B!JA0CV!K!K$N;kE@$G8+$k$H!"2<5-(B&#9832;$B$O!V2a9s;v8N!&J| &#9832;$B!J2J3X$NHb!K$_$N:nJ*!!  
$B%D%t%'%?%s!&%H%I%m%U$K$h$l$P!"%3%s%G%#%d%C%/!J(BE. B. de Condillac$B!?(B1714 - 1780$B!?1Q7P83O@$NIc%8%g%s!&(B.$B%m%C%/!J(BJohn Locke$B!?(B1632- 1704$B!K$+$i7hDjE*$J1F6A$r]E*$JJ,@O;W9M$r5-9f2=$7!"$=$l$i$rO@M}Bg7O2=$9$kF;$r3+$$$?!#(B

$B99$K$3$l$,%i%t%)%"%8%'!J%U%m%.%9%H%s@b!J"-"%!K$rO@GK$7$?$?$a6aBe2=3X$NIc$H$5$l$k!K$N2=3X5-9f$N@0M}$HBg7OE*L?L>K!$N9M0F!J2=3X3WL?!K$K7R$,$C$?!#B>J}!"2=3X!J85AG!K5-9f$=$N$b$N$N9M0F $B"%%U%m%.%9%H%s@b$O$J$<;Y;}$5$l$?$N$+!?1J0f=S:H%I%C%H%3%`!"(Bhttps://www.nagaitoshiya.com/ja/2011/phlogiston-theory/
$B!&!&!&(B 
$B$9$G$K!JA0CV!K$G?($l$F$-$?$3$H$@$,!"463P$H46>p$O@Z$jN%$7Fq$/?<$$4X78$K$"$k$H;W$o$l$k$,!V463P!a46>p!W$G$O$J$/!"$$$o$P!V463P!a46>p$N%(%s%H%i%s%9!W$H8@$&$Y$-$G$"$m$&!#F1$8$/!"!JA0CV!K$G4{$K=R$Y$?$H$*$j!"(BM.$B%"%s%j$O@dBPE*]3XE*$J!VM?7o!J8=$l!K!W$H$7$F!V46>p!W$NI==P$rA
$B$=$7$F!"$=$N@dBPE*p$N3$!W!JD61[O@E*>p46@-$N3H$,$j!?(Baffectivite$B!K$,B8:_$9$k$H8+$k$N$,(BM$B!&%"%s%j$NFCD'$G$"$C$?!#(B

$B$H$b$+$/$b!"$3$N$h$&$K%3%s%G%#%d%C%/$N!V463PO@!J$b$C$Q$i0EL[CN!K$N8&5f!W!J@h$:!c463PO@!d$r8&5f$7!"$d$,$F!c7P83O@E/3X!d$N8&5f$r7P$FCj>]E*$JJ,@O;W9M$r5-9f2=$7!"$=$l$i$rO@M}Bg7O2=$9$kF;$r3+$$$?Nr;K!K$,!"$=$l$O4V@\E*$G$"$C$?$H$O$$$(!"?k$K$O!"$=$l$,%i%t%)%"%8%'!J(BAntoine-Laurent de Lavoisier$B!?(B1743 - 1794$B!K$i$N%U%m%.%9%H%s@b$rD69n$7$F!V2=3X3WL?!W$r$b$?$i$9$3$H$K7R$,$C$?$H$$$&Nr;K$+$i!v!N
$B!v!N(B17 $B@$5*!V2J3X3WL?!A2=3X3WL?!W!A8=Be!VL1]$N%]%$%s%H!O(B

$B!|%K%e!<%H%sNO3X$N $B!|(B18$B@$5*!V%3%s%G%#%d%C%/$N2=3X3WL?!W!&!&!&!V7A<0CN!\0EL[CN!W$K$h$k(B
$B!|(B18$B@$5*!V2J3X3WL?$N40@.4|!W!&!&!&$b$C$Q$i7A<0CN$K$h$k(B
$B!|(B18$B!A(B19$B@$5*!V7ZE*$JM}@-!K$K$h$k(B
$B!|(B20$B@$5*!A!V8=BeL1H!*!K(B
$B!&!&!&(B

$B$3$NN.$l$+$iJ,$+$k$N$O!"$$$h$$$h(B21$B@$5*$3$=!"(BAI$B!&86;R3KJ*M}3X!J3K(B $BJ,NvH?1~!&3KM;9gH?1~!"B>!KEy$N@hC<2J3X$=$l<+BN$N$?$a$G$O$J$/!"$^$?%R%H$NK0$/$J$-2a>j!JL58B$N%*!<%P!<%U%m!j%5!<%S%92=$X$N4jK>!K$G$"$kM_K>$N$?$a$G$O$J$/!"$3$NCO5e$H$$$&<+A34D6-$N$J$+$G%R%H$,Ey$7$/9,$;$K@8$-$i$l$k$h$&!"$=$l$i@hC<2J3X5;=Q$i$rLrN)$?$;$k$?$a$N9-3Q$NE8K>$rM?$(B3$1$k$3$H$,2DG=$J!c4{B8%"%+%G%_%:%`$NNN0h$rD6$($?%3%s%7%j%(%s%9!"HcH=  
$B0x$_$K!"HcH=l$r:N$k<+A32J3X$H$$$($I$b<+$i$N!V2>@b!W$K0x$kO@M}Bg7O$N%U%m!@b$NE83+e$N!c4{B8%"%+%G%_%:%`$NNN0h$rD6$($?%3%s%7%j%(%s%9!"HcH=
$B$J$*!"%"%s%I%j%e!pJs!J(B&#9832;$B!K$r;2>H8p$&!#(B
 
 $B!J(B&#9832;$B!K%"%s%I%j%e!:\!=!!(Bhttp://www.nakanishiya.co.jp/book/b481631.html

$B%"%s%I%j%e!!!!K!'%$%.%j%9!"%i%s%+%9%?!o$K7k9g$7$F$$$k!#(B

$BFbMF@bL@!']$H8&5fL\E*$+$i!":GE,$N8&5f]$H8&5fL\E*$+$i!":GE,$N8&5fJ}K!$r3d$j=P$9$?$a$NJ}K!O@!#2$JF$G(B30$BG/$K$o$?$jHG$r=E$MB3$1$kL>Cx!"BTK>$N=iLu!#J}K!$r3d$j=P$9$?$a$NJ}K!O@!#2$JF$G(B30$BG/$K$o$?$jHG$r=E$MB3$1$kL>Cx!"BTK>$N=iLu!#(B

$B!JHcH=
$B@8B8$N8B3&$KD>LL$7$?@8L?$,?7$?$JE,1~NO$rE83+$7F@$k>r7o$O2?$+!)$K4X$o$k8=>]3XE*$JJ}K!O@$rC5$k$4$/?7$7$$35G0$,!V?HBN2=$5$l$??4!J%(%J%/%F%#%t%#%:%`!?(Benactivism$B!K!W$NLdBj$G$"$k!#FC$K!"%@%s!&%6%O%t%#$,!V8=>]3X$N<+A32=!W!J%"%P%&%H$K8@$($P!"%3%s%7%j%(%s%9!J!H?MJ82J3X!I$H!H2J3XCN!"FC$K?@7P@8M}3X!I$NM;9g!?  
$B!z#1(B $B%@%s!&%6%O%t%#!X%U%C%5!<%k$N0d;:!Y!=8=>]3X!"7A<)>e3X!"D61[O@E/3X!=!JAQ=q!&%&%K%Y%k%7%?%9!K(B
$B!&!&!&$=$b$=$b!V?HBN2=$5$l$??4!W$O!"%*!<%H%]%$%(!<%7%9O@$NAO;Oe$N%6%O%t%#$NCx=q!z#1$H$5$l$F$$$k!#$7$+$7!$99$KAL$l$P!V%(%J%/%F%#%t%#%:%`!W!J(Benactivism$B!K$NMQ8l$r=i$a$F;H$C$?$N$O%(%t%!%s!&%H%s%W%=%s$G$"$k$H;W$o$l$k!J"-!z#2!K!#(B
 
$B!z#2(B $B%t%!%l%i!"%H%s%W%=%s!"%m%C%7%eCx!'EDCfLwIWLu!X?HBN2=$5$l$??4!J(BThe Embodied Mind$B!K(B1991$B!Y!J(B2001$B!"9):n
$BFC$K!"$3$N!V?HBN2=$5$l$??4!W$O2J3XE*8=>]3X!J%+%s%HM3Mh$ND61[O@E*E/3X$N:G@hC<%U%#!<%k%I!K!"%@%$%J%_%+%k%7%9%F%`M}O@!J%2%7%e%?%k%H?4M}3X$NJ,Ln!K!"Bh;MCJ3,$KE~C#$7$?$H$5$l$k@hC<(BAI$B8&5f!J<+$i$r@$3&FbB8:_$G$"$k$H0U<1$G$-$k!"$$$o$f$k%O%$%G%,!
$B0x$_$K!"7+$jJV$7$K$J$k$,(BHKB$B%b%G%k!J?HBN(B-$B4D6-%7%9%F%`!&%b%G%k!"(Bhttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haken-Kelso-Bunz_model $B!K$r;H$C$?!V?@7P2J3X$K$*$1$k0U<18&5f!W!J?@7P8=>]3X!K$N:G@hC<$G$O!"!V0U<1$NFC@-$O;V8~@-!W$K$"$k$3$H$,#S(B.$B%.%c%i%,!IU$1$?!V8=>]3X$NA0E]$7!W!J(Bfront-loading phenomenology$B!K$H$$$&8&5f
$B$J$*!"?@7P8=>]3X(B(Neurophenomenology)$B$O(BF.$B#J(B.$B%t%!%l%i!J%A%j=P?H$NG'CN2J3X'$5$l$?%"%W%m!<%A$G!"0lHL$K-!BN83$N8=>]3XE*$JJ,@O!"-"NO3X7OM}O@!J%]%F%s%7%c%k4X?t!"E}0l>lM}O@$J$I!K!"-#@8J*3XE*%7%9%F%`$K4X$9$ke!"Ev@a!X%(%J%/%F%#%t%#%:%`!"4XO"!Y$N=PE5!aEv;v]3X$K@\9g$9$k!'@P869'Fs!&El5~Bg3X!&Bg3X1!Am9gJ82=8&5f2J!"(Bhttp://phsc.jp/dat/rsm/2013_a1-3.pdf$B!!!K(B

$B%V%i%&%6$NJD$8$k%\%?%s$GJD$8$F$/$@$5$$!#(B